Coursekit is now Lore.
What’s the Story?
A discovery engine for meaningful knowledge, fueled by cross-disciplinary curiosity.
A Brain Pickings project edited by Maria Popova in partnership with Noodle.
Twitter: @explorer

Here is another gem from this brilliant (as a physicist) moron: “Philosophy is a field that, unfortunately, reminds me of that old Woody Allen joke, ‘those that can’t do, teach, and those that can’t teach, teach gym.’ And the worst part of philosophy is the philosophy of science; the only people, as far as I can tell, that read work by philosophers of science are other philosophers of science. It has no impact on physics what so ever. … they have every right to feel threatened, because science progresses and philosophy doesn’t.”

Okay, to begin with, it is fair to point out that the only people who read works in theoretical physics are theoretical physicists, so by Krauss’ own reasoning both fields are largely irrelevant to everybody else (they aren’t, of course). Second, once again, the business of philosophy (of science, in particular) is not to solve scientific problems — we’ve got science for that … To see how absurd Krauss’ complaint is just think of what it would sound like if he had said that historians of science haven’t solved a single puzzle in theoretical physics. That’s because historians do history, not science. When was the last time a theoretical physicist solved a problem in history, pray?

You know the catfight is on when a philosopher calls a scientist a “brilliant moron.” Massimo Pigliucci responds to physicist Lawrence Krauss’s contention that philosophers feel threatened by scientists and science is making philosophy obsolete.

Along the way, the discussion adds to existing definitions of what science is and what philosophy is.

58 notes
  1. faltaestudo reblogged this from explore-blog
  2. sobrenadante reblogged this from explore-blog
  3. crognak reblogged this from soycrates
  4. taimur reblogged this from explore-blog
  5. soycrates reblogged this from jayaprada
  6. jayaprada reblogged this from metamelf
  7. metamelf reblogged this from explore-blog
  8. kudzumon reblogged this from explore-blog
  9. josdehart reblogged this from explore-blog
  10. hidekikamiya reblogged this from mostlytumbler
  11. jjarichardson reblogged this from explore-blog
  12. experimentallullaby reblogged this from explore-blog
  13. serenity5x5 reblogged this from explore-blog
  14. cookedcloset reblogged this from explore-blog
  15. thunder-nipples reblogged this from explore-blog
  16. minutesmomentsmesses reblogged this from explore-blog
  17. backasswords reblogged this from explore-blog
  18. herpicusderpicus reblogged this from explore-blog
  19. the-rx reblogged this from explore-blog